Yes, the rumors are true, the Screwged Cocktail is the holiday cocktail you want to be sipping on this year! If you're a fan of Screwball whiskey and love eggnog, the Christmas cocktail with whiskey is for YOU. An easy, quick, and dangerously good holiday cocktail with just three ingredients! Merry drinkmas friends, it's a WHOLE LOTTA YUM!
Christmas Cocktail with Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey
One thing I know for sure is that I'm obsessed with Screwball peanut butter whiskey drinks, and my hunch is that you're a lover of Screwball whiskey drinks too! If you're looking for Screwball peanut butter whiskey recipes, then you'll want to make our Christmas cocktail version with this liqueur, it will not disappoint.
I made the Screwged cocktail for my friend recently and her reaction was priceless. This truly is one of the best screwball cocktails! I have many friends who also love screwball peanut butter whiskey, so I was super excited to create this and wanted to make something everyone would enjoy.
Looking for more holiday cocktail recipes? Be sure to try our sugar cookie martini and Chocolate mini martini!
Ingredient Notes
The Screwged cocktail is easily the simplest yet addicting cocktail there is. Anyone will enjoy this and it's not the sugary holiday drink it might look like. Screwball peanut butter whiskey recipes are my absolute favorite, so I thought I'd make a spin of it with screwball and eggnog for the perfect Christmas cocktail!
- screwball whiskey (peanut butter flavored whiskey)
- eggnog - either regular eggnog, dairy free, or low fat
- milk of your choice, we love oat milk but you can use dairy milk, heavy whipping cream, or half n half for a richer flavor
- nutmeg
- whipped cream - the kind you spray to be used as your garnish
- cinnamon sticks
** Please see the recipe card at the bottom of the post for the exact quantities **
Equipment
- Shaker
- spoon
Screwball Drink Recipe Instructions
Make this festive cocktail recipe within five minutes and drink it just as quickly- it's that good. Do you want a Christmas cocktail with whiskey you can whip up for having friends over and a great way to have them stay longer? Leave it to the festive Screwball cocktails!
Assemble
- Pour ice into the shaker.
- Add Screwball, eggnog, and milk. Shake it up!
- Add a few ice cubes to the cocktail glass (optional) and pour the mixture in.
Decorate
- Take a spoon and spray whip cream across, then gently shake the spoon over the glass and place whip cream on the side.
- Lightly sprinkle with nutmeg and place a cinnamon stick in whipped cream.
- Enjoy and drink up!
Screwball Drinks Recipe Tips
- To tone the rich taste of the eggnog you can add more milk or dairy substitute
- Add more nutmeg for even more of a "kick" or add cinnamon or your favorite holiday spice.
- We purchased Screwball peanut butter whiskey and eggnog separately, in some markets they're making Screwball eggnog which can be used in place of the separate bottles of whiskey and eggnog.
- To make a pitcher, multiply the ingredients by 6.
Common Questions
What to Serve with the Screwged Cocktail?
The Screwged Cocktail is best served with any kind of holiday treat or a side of cheese and crackers. Any simple appetizers pair greatly as well!
How long does it keep?
This Screwball whiskey cocktail is still good to drink after 1-2 days in the fridge but is always best fresh! We recommend holding off on the garnishes until you serve the drink.
Where to Buy Screwball Eggnog?
Screwball Eggnog is hard to find around the holidays, and truth be told, our homemade Screwball eggnog recipe tastes even better! Screwball eggnog can be found at stores like Bevo, Sam's Club, Target, Safeway, Albertson's, Instacart, and others. Screwball isn't sold in all states so be sure to check out the Screwball website to see if it's sold near you.
What Goes Good with Screwball Whiskey?
Screwball whiskey is amazing on it's own, peanut butter shots anyone? If you want to mix Screwball Whiskey with something, here's our favorites:
- Heavy whipping cream
- Oat milk
- Eggnog! We make a mean Screwball eggnog recipe.
- Make a Screwball White Russian with kahlua, vodka, and half n half
- Mix in jam with cream to make a peanut butter and jelly drink.
More Holiday Cocktail Recipes
Come connect with us on Instagram! Be sure to tag us (wholelotta.yum) when you make a recipe. You can also find us on Facebook, and Pinterest.
Screwged Cocktail (With Screwball Peanut Butter Whiskey)
Yes, the rumors are true, the Screwged Cocktail is the Christmas cocktail you want to be sipping on this year! If you're a fan of Screwball peanut butter whiskey and love eggnog, the Screwged Cocktail is for YOU. Just three ingredients!
Ingredients
- 1 ½ oz screwball
- ¾ oz eggnog
- 1 oz milk
- garnishes- nutmeg, whipped cream, cinnamon sticks
Instructions
- Pour ice into a shaker. Add the Screwball, eggnog, and milk. Shake it up!
- Add a few ice cubes to the cocktail glass (optional) and pour the mixture in.
- Take a spoon and spray whip cream across, then gently shake the spoon over the glass and place whip cream on the side.
- Lightly sprinkle with nutmeg and place a cinnamon stick in whip cream. Enjoy and drink up!
Notes
If you love Screwball whiskey drinks, be sure to save our pin to Pinterest for later!
Leave a Reply