Grilled Cheese in Air Fryer

Did you know that you can make grilled cheese in air fryer?! It’s a fantastic way to create that super delicious, warm, and crispy sandwich and a great way to get kids started in the kitchen and cooking! This air fryer grilled cheese recipe is a WHOLE LOTTA YUM way to spend just 15-minutes cooking and create lifelong memories.

Jump to:

• Air Fryer Grilled Cheese
• Ingredient Notes
• Step by Step Instructions
• Recipe Tips
• Common Questions
• More Air Fryer Recipes
• Grilled Cheese in Air Fryer

 

Air Fryer Grilled Cheese

There is something so nostalgic about a grilled cheese sandwich. Warm and toasty on the outside, soft and cheesy on the inside, and a reminder of home cooking. Growing up, it was one of my children’s favorite sandwiches and a request that was easy to accommodate.

Whether we were serving our grilled cheese alongside a can of soup, getting fancy with an Italian Tortelli soup, or pairing it with my personal favorite, this pressure cooker chicken noodle, there is something perfect about a dinner of soup and sandwiches.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Grilled cheese in air fryer is just as simple as the stovetop version.
• Create a perfectly customized air fryer grilled cheese by choosing from your favorite bread and cheese combinations.
• Keep your sandwich simple by opting for just bread and cheese, or get creative by adding in bacon, ham, or tomato.
• Teach your kids how to cook with a recipe that is perfect for little chefs everywhere.
• The whole recipe needs just 3 ingredients!

Create a quick and simple meal with air fryer snacks including air fryer frozen waffle fries, air fryer frozen pizza, and air fryer frozen chicken nuggets! Not only are these all kid-approved recipes, but they are also easy enough to let your little cooks take the lead in the kitchen with.

On Keto? Grab our FREE keto foods list here OR  Snag our Keto  Binder HERE

Ingredient Notes

Two slices of your favorite bread, a slice of your favorite cheese, and some butter are all you need to create your grilled cheese in air fryer.

• bread
• cheddar cheese slices
• butter

Variations

• Bread – Any variety of bread will work for your air fryer grilled cheese including white, wheat, thin French bread slices, gluten-free bread, keto bread, or sprouted grain bread.
• Cheese – Cheddar may be considered classic, but you can also make your grilled cheese in air fryer with mozzarella, Monterey Jack, Gruyere, or even American.
• Butter – You can opt to use margarine or another butter substitute, or omit this ingredient altogether.

Equipment

An Air Fryer– We have an Omni Plus oven style air fryer and a small 3.2L Farberware basket style air fryer. 

Diet Adaptions

• Vegan– In place of the cheese, use a plant-based cheese substitute. Omit butter or use a vegan-friendly alternative.
• Gluten-Free– Opt for gluten-free bread.
• Keto– Use a low-carb or keto-approved bread.

Step by Step Instructions

No more work than a traditional grilled cheese, your grilled cheese in air fryer just needs a few minutes of your time and a plate.

Prep

Lightly brush your bread with room-temperature butter on one side only.

Place two slices of thinly sliced cheddar cheese in between the bread slices, overlapping the cheese if needed so it is not sticking out of the bread. The buttered side of the bread should be facing out.

Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Temp

Preheat your air fryer to 380F. Allow the unit to warm for 5-minutes. Most air fryer models will preheat automatically, but if yours does not, turn the unit to 380F and allow it to run for 5 minutes before you begin cooking.

Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Cooking Time

Place the prepared sandwich in your preheated air fryer and cook the air fryer grilled cheese sandwich for 5-minutes.

Flip the sandwich over with a non-stick spatula and cook for an additional 5 minutes.

Your air fryer grilled cheese will need to cook for a total of 9-10 minutes until the cheese is melted and the bread is golden brown.

Serve warm. Enjoy!

Recipe Tips

• Make sure the cheese is not hanging over the edge of the bread because it’ll melt and spread over the sides during cooking.
• Preheating your air fryer ensures that your grilled cheese begins cooking immediately.
• Your grilled cheese in air fryer is done when the bread’s exterior reaches your preferred crispness.
• For best results, serve immediately.
• If making multiple sandwiches you are going to need to cook in batches. Do not stack or overlap air fryer grilled cheese.

Common Questions

More Air Fryer Recipes

Looking for more air fryer recipes?

• Frozen Waffle Fries in Air Fryer
• Air Fryer Chicken Wings Dry Rub
• Air Fryer Turkey Bacon
• Frozen Pizza in Air Fryer
• Hot pockets in air fryer